Dumb and Dumberer

Review by Jay Pinkerton

View This Trailer


While reading through the bags full of Trailer Trash fan mail I receive each week, I sometimes come across the occasional criticism of my reviews: I am, it seems, just "too darn hard" on trailers.

I personally think that's a damned shamefaced lie — even a casual reader of the site could immediately see that I'm an objective paragon of unbiased virtue. Take a look at some excerpts of my past reviews, for example:

"Blade II is a virulent, gaping pustule on the fat buttock of humanity. Wesley Snipes should be thrashed with a sack of ripe potatoes until he no longer resembles the character Blade, thus preventing his appearance in further sequels."

"Anthony Hopkins is a good actor. So his appearance in the trailer for Bad Company can only be explained by the following hypotheses: He had a stroke, followed by a more massive stroke, then a consecutive barrage of worse and worse strokes right up to the point where he showed up on the set; He confused the script's title for a biopic on the seminal late 70's rock band of the same name, and a sentimental love of their hit 'Can't Get Enough' clouded his judgment; A routine Q-Tip ear-swabbing went tragically awry."

"The trailer for The Scorpion King is akin to a minute and a half of liquid diarrhea, if the diarrhea had one giant eyebrow attached to it. The Rock appears so jacked up throughout, it's a wonder his nipples don't dispense eight flavors of anadrol when his co-stars brush by his pectorals."

These seem fine to me. I don't get what all the fuss is about. However, in the interest of total fairness in reviewing the New Line Cinema trailer Dumb and Dumberer: When Harry Met Lloyd, I have elected for a Trailer Trash first. I have assembled a focus group, randomly selected from average, everyday people across America, to assist me in this review. If they find the trailer for Dumb and Dumberer as reprehensible as I do, it will prove the even-handedness of my reviews to those slack-jawed meatheads who thought otherwise. I am merely a voice for the people; alas, my words are not mine, but instead the words of history.

If, against all reason, my focus group enjoys the trailer for Dumb and Dumberer, I will have to entertain the idea that I'm too hard on Hollywood, and learn to be more forgiving in the future. This path, I can see, will lead inevitably down a slippery slope into a dark, dark valley from which no light escapes, where a future Me reclines forever on a plush couch eating spoonfuls of bacon fat and laughing like a Down's Syndrome-afflicted hyena at non-stop viewings of Joe Dirt. Naturally, I was hoping my focus group would pull through, or I'd have no recourse but to beat them savagely.

"I'm sorry, what?" asked a member of my focus group.

"I said I'll have no recourse but to beat you savagely. Let's begin."

 

Experiment #1: Trailer Viewing

In a controlled environment deep within the heart of Trailer Trash's high-tech laboratory, I gave all fifty members of my focus group a laptop with the trailer ready to play. I toyed momentarily with the idea of using metal devices to keep their eyes open like in Clockwork Orange, but abandoned this on the grounds that it seemed like a lot of work, and I had no idea how I'd be able to race around moistening the eyeballs of fifty subjects, short of spitting in their eyes. This suggestion was shouted down by my focus group, and we abandoned the eye clamp idea entirely.

The Dumb and Dumberer trailer was then cued up, as my fifty test subjects watched it and checked off their impressions on an impartial survey.

 

Results of Experiment

I leafed through the surveys while my focus group played Minesweeper on their laptops. Some of the results:

Test Subject #5: as far as i see it now it has everything what the first one had and to make a good second part you must give it what the first part had just with a new story and ofcours new things if they did that they would have a pretty good movie if they just had carrey and daniels in it and make a part Afther the first part NoT BeFoRe!! then i think the movie would be a best one but as i see it now it will have nothing what make the first one that good they will really surprise me if the movie will be asgood!! when i heard about the second part i thought yes Harry And Lloyd will come again but from the moment i saw that carrey and daniels won't play in it i just tought why??

Test Subject #44: At first when i heard this rumor i was floored to hear that they would do another movie at first because i heard they would'nt be in it and Dumb and dumber goe's down as one of the allmost funiest movies of all time so too have these 2 guys back for another movie that wasnt expected would be amazing and funny!!! literally comedy gold!!!!!

Test Subject #17: 3 things. 1 this looks great!!!! 2 I think it wont be as good as the first dumb and dumberer but still real funny or should I say dumberer!!!! one of the best things what make dumb & dumber that good was that carrey and daniels where just perfect to be with in the movie they make the movie simpley funnie!!

Test Subject #23: Comedic gem!! Everytime I look at his characters chiped tooth I laughed harder then I laughed not as hard when I watched dude wheres my car and that was funny and same with Jeff Daniel's!!! This trailers hilarious from beggining to end and I love Jim Carey making Dumb and Dumberer a comedy reccommendation from me to anyone

Test Subject #31: maby many people think how can they bring on the story afther the first part but i think that will just be a surprize for everybody untill you see it and i really think the movie will be great i remeber when dumb and dumber 1 was in production many people said that it will suck well as you see it became eving better that we think so lets hope this one will to many people don't think so but how can you know you haven't seen it o it's still a surprize how it will be now mather how much you read or see about the movie it's still a surprize how the story will go on and a good thing about a new part is a surprize in it!!

Suddenly it dawned on me. Through whatever twist of fate I'd somehow chosen morons — fat illiterate morons — for my focus group.

"Test Subject #23?" I said to the group. "Could you please stand up?" A heavy-set teenage girl with a glazed blank look struggled for a minute with the sheer weight of all her superfluous chromosomes, then stood.

"Test Subject #23, you are aware that Jim Carrey isn't actually IN this movie? His character is being played by someone else entirely."

Test Subject #23's brow furrowed. "Was too Jim Carrey. Had a chipped tooth an' everything."

I stood up slowly. "Test Subject #23, the character was eighteen years old in the trailer. Jim Carrey's in his thirties."

"'S'a good actor," she said, folding her ample, dimpled arms across her ampler, bad-to-think-about chest.

"Yeah, he in that Truman Show," said someone else. "He winned an Oscar and everything."

"No he didn't!" I protested, to blank stares. "Did no one here notice the roles were played by completely different actors?"

"That chipped tooth was the awesome comedic gem," someone in the back piped up.

"I loved it when he will fart," added another with an air of authority.

"Okay, new experiment," I decided.

 

Experiment #2: Supervised Trailer Viewing

In this experiment I chose to supervise the subjects, one at a time, as they watched the trailer. At the first sign of any enjoyment at all, I would open-palm slap them, as hard as possible, across the face.

Test Subject #37: "Huh huh huh…"

Me: [open-palm slapping subject's face] "No! Wrong! Wrong! That is why you're wrong!"

Trailer: [shows Coke machine falling on actor; actor farts]

Test Subject #37: "Uh huh huh huh huh…"

Me: [slapping subject's face with such force a rear molar flies across room] "NO! STOP! EVERYTHING YOU THINK TRUE AND PURE IS WRONG!" [slap slap slap slap] "I WILL BEAT SMART INTO YOU OR KILL YOU TRYING!"

 

Results of Experiment

19 minor injuries, 12 hospitalizations, some blood loss. I was forced to conclude that you can't actually beat stupid out of someone. You can, however, beat a glutinous pink jelly-like substance out of someone, if you hit hard enough. It comes out of their noses. I hadn't known that before.

 

Experiment #3: Trailer Viewing w/Shock Therapy

Results of Experiment: FAILURE

Experiment #4: Trailer Viewing in Centrifuge Reaching Speeds of 300 rpm

Results of Experiment: FAILURE

Experiment #5: Trailer Viewing w/Russian Roulette-Style Firearm Motivation

Results of Experiment: FAILURE

Experiment #6: Locking Subjects in Room; Burning Building to Dust & Ashes

Results of Experiment: UNQUALIFIED SUCCESS

 

Conclusion

As I sprayed the gasoline around, I could hear muffled yells from the other side of the locked door. "We liked the trailer, stop!" Then some hushed whispering. "Okay now we didn't also like the trailer! It was not the comedic gem!" As I lit the match on my way out, my heart filled with gladness that I'd finally managed, somehow, to reach them. Moments like that — and of course the screams, always the screams — are what make these efforts worthwhile.

So: given the deathbed confessions, I can state for the record that not one subject in the Trailer Trash Focus Group enjoyed the trailer for Dumb and Dumberer. And, as the only witness to their confession, I can additionally state for the record that their choices were not coerced in any way. With this inarguable evidence at my side, I can proudly say to the naysayers: eat me. I'll take out the trash because I speak for the people, goddammit.

Also, I guess the trailer wasn't that bad. Two and a half Billys.

RATING:

 

A note on the subjects' trailer comments: to achieve as much realism as possible, these critiques were assembled from actual user comments on IMDb.com. If you should recognize any of the randomly-placed punctuation, apostrophes used to pluralize words, or labarynthine, adverb-free sentences to be your own, please write me with a long, long letter in complaint. Feel free to elaborate as much as you feel is necessary to get your point across.